With the remake of The Wicker Man coming out next week, I have been trying to put my finger on why this remake upsets me so much. I do know why I love the original - it is quirky, silly and yet still manages to make you really uncomfortable. There are no crazy special effects, foreboding music or monsters to manipulate your fear - you are in a completely realistic situation and the characters are all logical (as logical as any group with strong religious beliefs).
Neil LaBute's version of the film goes a different route - from the trailer it seems that the film is a complete turn from the original minus some plot points - Neil LaBute has said he was aware of that, but his goal was to achieve the same effect that the original had, but with different means -
It remains to be seen whether his effort will be successful - but I do know that while gimmickry may work in the moment; it will not have the lasting impact of well crafted ambience.
In the cinema we were re-born as global citizens in defiance of the tyranny of the time and the isolation of the space that sought to confine us. In cinema, everything was possible, and in that possibility we defied our paralyzing limitations. The cinema revealed our hidden hopes as nation. With all the political and religious censorship that brutally limited our visual pleasures and experiences, we reveled in the rainbows of images that colored our cinematic daydreams.”
from Hamid Dabashi’s “Close Up Iranian Cinema ______
for project film school screenings info visit : http://projectfilmschool.org
1 comment:
With the remake of The Wicker Man coming out next week, I have been trying to put my finger on why this remake upsets me so much. I do know why I love the original - it is quirky, silly and yet still manages to make you really uncomfortable. There are no crazy special effects, foreboding music or monsters to manipulate your fear - you are in a completely realistic situation and the characters are all logical (as logical as any group with strong religious beliefs).
Neil LaBute's version of the film goes a different route - from the trailer it seems that the film is a complete turn from the original minus some plot points - Neil LaBute has said he was aware of that, but his goal was to achieve the same effect that the original had, but with different means -
It remains to be seen whether his effort will be successful - but I do know that while gimmickry may work in the moment; it will not have the lasting impact of well crafted ambience.
Post a Comment